Europeanisation of Administrative Justice?

The Influence of the ECJ's Case Law in Italy, Germany and England

By Mariolina Eliantonio

Some 40 years after the landmark judgment of the European Court of Justice (ECJ) in van Gend en Loos, the impact of European law on the administrative laws of the Member States of the European Union has manifested itself intensely, and in many different aspects, because of the influence of both the ECJ and of EC legislation. This impact is particularly striking in relation to administrative law, because, as a part of public law, administrative law had long been deemed an area of monopoly of the State and a clear outgrowth of the State's sovereign powers that precluded interference from any other jurisdiction. As of today, European law influences virtually all areas of substantive administrative law, administrative organization, decision-making proceedings, and judicial protection. Amongst those areas, this book focuses on the influence of the ECJ's case law on five selected aspects of the Italian, German, and English rules on the judicial review of administrative action. Taking as a starting point the ECJ's case law on domestic remedies, the book reports the results of an investigation as to whether, and to what extent, the national courts have applied the standards of protection set out in the ECJ's case law. Furthermore, it is investigated whether, in the areas in which a process of Europeanization has taken place, the ECJ's case law has contributed to an increasing similarity between the three legal systems. Finally, the book discusses whether, for the purposes of ensuring an effective judicial protection of Community rights, the rules on the decentralized enforcement of EC law in administrative courts should be harmonized by the European legislator.


416 pages

Publication Date: 1/1/2009
Format: Paper
ISBN: 9789076871974